March 4, 2010
William Shakespe atomic number 18s translucent depiction of Portia and moneylenders opinions in A merchant of Venice allow readers to adequately lend the voice of these characters to contemporary views of justice. In A Masque of Mercy, Robert Frost says, nothing stool carry injustice just but forbearance. This prolific statement can be phrased as a question: When applied to an dirty situation, does mercy rectify that situation and make it just? Not surprisingly, Shylock and Portias likely responses to this question are starkly different. In fact, both views, despite being opposites of each other, are correct. The perceptiveness and severity used in one model cannot be transposed with the clemency and conclude granted in another.
Based on Shakespeares portrayal of Shylock in A Merchant of Venice, Shylock would disagree with Robert Frosts statement. Furthermore, during Antonios trial, the Duke asks Shylock how he expects mercy to be shown unto him if he does not show mercy to others. Shylock curtly retorts, What judgment shall I dread, doing no wrong? He believes that by citing a legal document in the case against Antonio (who previously snubbed him), who has unconnected his word and the bond, his methods are just; although he is motivated by merciless vengeance, his actions are plausible.
He seeks the full measure of Venetian law, undiluted by mercy. Oddly enough, Shylocks reasoning is not rooted in the law which he craves (pp. 69, 19). He is incapable of being merciful. The merchant explains his rationale: As there is no firm reason to be renderd, / So can I give no reason, nor I lead not, / More than a lodged hate and a certain execrate (pp. 64-65). He cannot explicitly state what drives his actions; there is no negotiating with a man who does not the reason behind his exploits. Therefore, in this case, revenge and mercy can never coexist.
In contrast to Shylocks response to Frosts quote, Portia would agree that mercy is needed to...If you want to get a full essay, baffle it on our website: Orderessay
If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .
No comments:
Post a Comment