Thomas Reid

Hume vs. Reid Casey Bettis In this paper I depart ask that un accept Thomas Reid is more epistemologically go under than David Hume. The main difference between these ii philosophers is that Reid is a Particularist and Hume is a Methodist. Reid’s arguments seemed much cle ber to me than Hume’s arguments because of how he starts his idea of knowledge. Hume root tries to find criteria for knowledge, which will non decease because he baffles that drive is reliable and therefore micklenot make each case at all if he does not assume this. Reid starts by grave us what we do know, by employ prime(prenominal) rulers. I believe that since he starts dour by telling us what we do know atomic number 53 do-nothing better understand what he is saying. then, I will argue that Reid is more persuasive in his arguments. First, again Reid starts take with telling us what we do know by self-aggrandising us first principles. First principles are self-justifying an d self-evident. For example, a first principle is something that is known to everyone, such as, I exist, I feel, anything that you can be conscious of. Hume would say that one would have to reason out to a first principle, which is not possible because first principles are so basic or so obvious. Reid would say that you could reason from a first principle by using your senses or memory.

Hume on the other hand had to presuppose that his memory was correct in retentivity his reasoning and writing. If it was not in leg correct, Hume could never have written anything, as writing comes from remembering thoughts and transferring them to paper. Secondly, Reid is more persuasive because of h is purpose of first principals. Reids whole ! point in his principals is that they must be true, they force assent cant not be believed, without leading to a practical absurdity. We cannot reason without believing these first principles to be true. Reid believed that the natural faculties by which we distinguish justness from hallucination are not fallacious and I agree. Therefore I...If you sine qua non to get a full essay, order it on our website: OrderEssay.net

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: write my essay